GOOD COMPANY FOR YOUR GO-TO

If you like Torchbearer Mushroom Mayhem, try these 5.

A familiar kind of different: related flavors, nearby heat, and room for a new favorite.

Torchbearer Mushroom Mayhem bottle
YOUR STARTING BOTTLE

Torchbearer Mushroom Mayhem

Extra hot

Shiitake and portobello mushroom powders add savory depth to a habanero-scorpion blend with horseradish and molasses.

Fine-tune the flavor

Good choice. Let’s find its next-door neighbors.

Ghost peppers, onion, bell pepper and garlic make a smooth, slightly creamy sauce with a delayed heat.

ghost pepperoniongarlic

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Ghost Hot: 2 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: Not established; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: Not established; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: Not establishedHeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Pickled ghost peppers combine with carrots, onion, garlic and lime in this Vermont-made recipe.

pickled peppercarrotlime

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Old Coy Dog: 2 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: Not established; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: Not established; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: Not establishedHeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Roasted red peppers and tomatoes frame Carolina Reaper heat, with soy, ginger and cardamom lending an Asian-inspired direction.

roasted peppergingersoy

More garlicky, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Foo Foo Mama Choo: 5 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: 2/5; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 1/5; Garlicky: 3/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: 5/5HeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Scorpion peppers intensify a koji-based sauce, retaining the savory character of rice koji alongside sherry vinegar, olive oil and garlic.

kojiumamiScorpion

Less savory / umami, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Scorpion Koji: 3 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: Not established; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: Not established; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: 4/5HeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Carolina Reaper, chipotle and shallots meet balsamic and white wine vinegars, with honey and brown sugar adding a little sweetness.

Reaperbalsamic vinegarshallot

Less sweet, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Reaper Sauce: 4 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: 1/5; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 2/5; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: Not establishedHeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Based on shared flavor notes and heat, not a promise that two bottles taste identical. Your palate gets the final vote.

Keep exploring with a swipe