GOOD COMPANY FOR YOUR GO-TOIf you like Melinda's Amarillo Habanero Hot Mustard Sauce, try these 5.
A familiar kind of different: related flavors, nearby heat, and room for a new favorite.

YOUR STARTING BOTTLEMelinda's Amarillo Habanero Hot Mustard Sauce
MediumYellow mustard and habanero make a punchy alternative to ordinary sandwich mustard.
Fine-tune the flavor Good choice. Let’s find its next-door neighbors.
Serrano peppers, tomato and basil take this white-wine-vinegar sauce in a distinctly Italian-inspired direction.
basiltomatogarlic
More sweet, with a similar heat range.
Flavor & heat
Avocado, cilantro, garlic and spring onion are paired with lime and dried superhot chiles in this green sauce.
avocadocilantrogarlic
Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.
Flavor & heat
Roasted Hatch chiles, jalapeños and garlic sit behind a crisp vinegar opening, with cilantro and a little Scorpion pepper.
roasted Hatchvinegaryroasted garlic
Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.
Flavor & heat
A Mexican-inspired chile blend pairs roasted tomato with garlic, cumin and lime for an earthy table sauce.
CuminRoasted tomatoEarthy
More sweet, with a similar heat range.
Flavor & heat
Nopal cactus joins green habanero, garlic and key lime in this green sauce.
CactusCitrusyGarlicky
Less savory / umami, with a similar heat range.
Flavor & heat
Based on shared flavor notes and heat, not a promise that two bottles taste identical. Your palate gets the final vote.
Keep exploring with a swipe