GOOD COMPANY FOR YOUR GO-TO

If you like Benito's Hot Sauce Old Coy Dog, try these 5.

A familiar kind of different: related flavors, nearby heat, and room for a new favorite.

Benito's Hot Sauce Old Coy Dog bottle
YOUR STARTING BOTTLE

Benito's Hot Sauce Old Coy Dog

Extra hot

Pickled ghost peppers combine with carrots, onion, garlic and lime in this Vermont-made recipe.

Fine-tune the flavor

Good choice. Let’s find its next-door neighbors.

Ghost peppers, onion, bell pepper and garlic make a smooth, slightly creamy sauce with a delayed heat.

ghost pepperoniongarlic

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Ghost Hot: 2 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: Not established; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: Not established; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: Not establishedHeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Shiitake and portobello mushroom powders add savory depth to a habanero-scorpion blend with horseradish and molasses.

mushroomumamimolasses

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Mushroom Mayhem: 6 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: 2/5; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 1/5; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: 1/5; Savory / umami: 5/5HeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Carolina Reaper, chipotle and shallots meet balsamic and white wine vinegars, with honey and brown sugar adding a little sweetness.

Reaperbalsamic vinegarshallot

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Reaper Sauce: 4 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: 1/5; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 2/5; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: Not establishedHeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Smoked habaneros turn the familiar carrot-and-lime recipe toward barbecue-friendly depth.

SmokyCarrotTangy

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
Smokin' Marie: 6 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: 2/5; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 5/5; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: 2/5; Savory / umami: 3/5HeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Smoked Reaper and habanero join ghost pepper and cayenne, with tomato, red wine vinegar, basil, oregano and garlic behind the heat.

smokytomatoherbs

Similar documented flavor notes, with a similar heat range.

Flavor & heat
All In: 4 of 6 flavors scored. Heat: Extra hot (4/5). Sweet: Not established; Sour / tangy: 3/5; Smoky: 3/5; Garlicky: 2/5; Fruity: Not established; Savory / umami: 2/5HeatSweetSour /tangySmokyGarlickyFruitySavory /umami05

Based on shared flavor notes and heat, not a promise that two bottles taste identical. Your palate gets the final vote.

Keep exploring with a swipe